The Politicization of Islam: Essays on Democratic Governance







The Politicization of Islam: Essays on Democratic Governance

Reviewed by LCDR Youssef Aboul-Enein, USN

Mohammed Eihachmi Hamdi. Westview Press (www.westviewpress.com), 5500 Central Avenue, Boulder, Colorado 80301. 206 pages, 1998.

Among Islamic militant circles, the Tunisian Al-Nahda (Renaissance) Party is held up as a model of modern Islamic governance. It's ideologue Rachid Ghannouchi has written several books that combined elements of liberal democracy, socialism and heavy doses of Islamic fundamentalist theories to come up with an appealing system of governance. This has led to western scholars like Dr. John Esposito to claim that this represents the moderation of Islamic political thought. Mohammed Eihachmi Hamdi is a Tunisian editor of the magazine Diplomat and a pan-Arab newspaper Mustakilla. His book is derived from his doctoral dissertation at the University of London and offers a historical and ideological glimpse into the unique nature of Tunisian Islamic activism.

The book begins by taking readers through the origins of Islamic political activism in the campuses of Tunisian colleges. 1967 would be a pivotal year, as many Tunisians sought answers for the Six-Day War and the failures of Arab nationalism. Rachid Ghannouchi, who was enamoured with Nasser would find his self-identity shattered by the Six-Day War and would look towards theology to reclaim a new identity. During this time he was a student in Syria and joined the Syrian Islamic Brotherhood. From Damascus he went for advanced studies in Paris. Another defining event for Ghannouchi is the 1979 Iranian Revolution, from which he began to derive a philosophy of organizing Islamist groups under constitutional framework. This framework included:

Majlis al-Shura, small parliament or legislative branch made up of 14 members;

Executive bureaus run by an amir (leader);

Ummal, which are provincial leaders selected by the amir;

Wukala, bureaucrats who run day to day provincial affairs;

University division, that works solely in recruitment and organizing campus activities and demonstrations;

Secondary Schools division, that plans activities within schools;

Cells, that train would-be members for three years before granting full membership, the curriculum is indoctrination into the ideals of the Islamic brotherhood.

When analyzing key manifestos of the Tunisian Islamic movements, embedded language such as a rejection of violence to bring about change, a rejection of the one-party system and support for trade unions. On its face, Ghannouchi may sound reasonable but careful analysis shows such clauses such as liberating the Muslim conscience from the civilizational defeat by the West and a commitment to assist liberation movements around the world. He argues that non- Muslims in a Muslim polity gain the right to practice their faith but give up their rights for political leadership. Ghannouchi writes that an independent judiciary and free press is necessary to serve as a check on the Islamic executive. Make no mistake however; such mixture of liberal democratic ideas within a Tunisian Islamist framework betrays the fact that Ghannouchi draws his inspiration from Islamic militant leaders. He dedicates his book Civil Liberties and the Islamic State to the Sudanese Sheikh Hassan Al-Turabi and the late Palestinian Sheikh Abdullah Azzam both have mentored Usama Bin Laden.

Take time to read Hamdi's work and understand Rachid Ghannouchi who represents the moderate face of Islamic militancy. His ideas will no doubt be used as a means of political discourse between jihadists and the government they wish to topple whether by force or using the electoral system in place.

2004, Foreign Area Officer Association
Herndon, Virginia
Maintained by LTC Steve Gotowicki.
http://www.faoa.org